Join CleanTechnica’s Weekly Substack for Zach and Scott’s in-depth analyses and excessive stage summaries, join our each day publication, and/or comply with us on Google Information!
I’ve been rebalancing my portfolio currently. It’s one thing I do each couple of years—trim what’s run forward, add the place conviction has deepened, and regulate primarily based on what I now imagine to be actual, sturdy worth. I’m not a dealer. I purchase and maintain for years, typically many years, and whereas my portfolio leans closely towards the digital and electrification of every little thing, therefore my current battery EFT evaluation, I regulate the corners of the vitality transition the place electrons alone received’t lower it. That brings me, inevitably, to biofuels. And to be clear, this isn’t funding recommendation. I’m sharing my reasoning, not providing you a goal allocation or value level. Do your individual diligence, or ignore the sector solely. That stated, right here’s what I discovered value contemplating and why.
As I famous within the battery evaluation, I used to be lastly shoved out of my procrastination by Pearl Jam. Effectively, at the very least by Stone Gossard, the guitarist for the grunge band. A mutual contact linked us because the band places a carbon value of $200 per ton on its live shows and invests the ensuing pool of money in fixing the local weather. Now they understand, like a whole lot of different folks, that doing good and earning profits are synonymous. We talked local weather investing a few weeks in the past, and that triggered me to lastly put my very own pool of money—smaller—into motion once more.
Biofuels have by no means been the middle of the vitality transition, and so they by no means will likely be. That position belongs to renewably-generated electrical energy and the batteries and grids that transfer it. However liquid fuels will persist—significantly within the components of transport and trade that resist electrification. Lengthy-haul aviation is the obvious instance. You’re not going to fly a narrow-body throughout the Pacific on battery energy, not this decade and never the following. Likewise, in maritime delivery, even with battery-electric coastal operations gaining floor, ocean-crossing vessels will nonetheless want dense, flamable vitality carriers. Hydrogen and e-fuels proceed to draw headlines, however their economics and thermodynamics stay unfavorable for many use instances. Biofuels—when derived from waste biomass and deployed in sectors that really want them—provide a extra grounded, scalable resolution.
Nonetheless, as an investor, this can be a arduous area. Loads of early biofuel bets imploded: poor margins, poor feedstock methods, poor timing. Some leaned too closely on meals crops, drawing justified criticism and volatility when commodity costs spiked. Others burned via money chasing futuristic pathways that had been years too early. The query, for somebody constructing a portfolio for the lengthy haul, will not be which agency has essentially the most thrilling press launch. It’s who’s already working at scale, with actual clients, actual income, and a defensible moat. And among the many pure-play corporations with little to no fossil gasoline publicity, 4 firms emerged as value my time: Neste, Darling Substances, UPM Kymmene, and Aemetis.
Let’s begin the place the dialog all the time ought to—with feedstock. Biofuels don’t start within the lab or on the pump. They start on the fryer, the sector, the forest ground. And whoever controls or integrates feedstock provide is already enjoying a distinct sport than these reliant on spot markets. Neste, the Finnish chief in renewable diesel and sustainable aviation gasoline (SAF), operates a world provide chain that spans three continents. It sources used cooking oil, animal fat, and different residues, pre-treats them at scale, and converts them into high-quality drop-in fuels utilizing proprietary hydroprocessing tech. It’s the largest producer of SAF on the earth at present. What it lacks in fossil scale, it greater than makes up for in logistics, coverage fluency, and execution.
Darling Substances, a much less well-known identify, is arguably much more safe on feedstock. It collects and renders about 10% of the world’s inedible animal by-products—actually the fats and bone left after livestock are processed—and turns a good portion into low-carbon fuels through its 50-50 three way partnership with Valero, Diamond Inexperienced Diesel. That JV is now the second-largest renewable diesel producer on the planet, with capability nearing 1.2 billion gallons per 12 months. The synergy is textbook: Darling provides the feedstock, Valero provides the refining and distribution infrastructure, and the gasoline flows into markets like California, the place LCFS credit stack on high of federal subsidies. The money movement from the JV exhibits up constantly in Darling’s books, offsetting volatility elsewhere in its animal feed and fertilizer enterprise.
UPM Kymmene, a Finnish forest merchandise agency, has a really completely different profile—extra industrial conglomerate than vitality firm. However it’s been quietly changing tall oil, a by-product of its pulp mills, into renewable diesel at its Lappeenranta biorefinery for practically a decade. This isn’t speculative. It’s operational, built-in, and compliant with Europe’s most stringent superior biofuel standards. The quantity is small—about 100,000 tonnes per 12 months—however the margins are wholesome, and the feedstock is totally captive. UPM is presently deciding whether or not to construct a brand new 500,000-tonne biorefinery that would come with SAF, and if it does, it’ll deliver the identical integration logic with it: utilizing its personal forestry residue streams, positioned adjoining to its present industrial clusters, to create fuels the place there’s already logistics and vitality out there. It’s transferring slowly, however with capital self-discipline and a transparent view of the regulatory panorama.
Aemetis rounds out the listing because the highest-risk, highest-potential candidate. Primarily based in California, it operates an ethanol plant at present and is constructing out each a renewable diesel and SAF refinery in addition to a dairy manure biogas community. The property are actual, the offtake agreements are spectacular—Delta, Japan Airways, and ten others have signed multi-year SAF provide contracts—and the LCFS and federal incentive stack in California makes the income projections look enticing. However this isn’t but a constantly worthwhile enterprise. It’s a capital-intensive transition play that depends upon execution. In the event that they construct their initiatives on time and on finances, they may turn out to be a significant SAF participant. If not, it could possibly be a cautionary story. For now, I deal with it as a speculative progress place—a small piece of the portfolio with a very long time horizon.
From a pure funding rating perspective, Neste is in a league of its personal. It combines scale, diversification, and coverage fluency with a high-integrity ESG story and continued margin energy, even in a turbulent 12 months. Its draw back for me is that it’s nonetheless working a legacy oil and gasoline refinery, however like Orsted, it’s exiting the fossil gasoline trade quickly and I imagine its dedication. Darling is shut behind, because of its unparalleled feedstock integration and the dependable money movement from Diamond Inexperienced Diesel. UPM is the low-beta, high-discipline decide—much less upside, however sturdy integration and stability sheet. As I’m bullish on engineered mass timber and hydroelectric, that it has plywood and hydro in its property is one thing I’m comfy with. Aemetis is the decision choice on SAF progress—too early to inform, however too well-positioned to disregard.
All of them are effectively off the 2021 clear funding bubble costs, so they’re worth priced now. And Trump’s tariffs have depressed all shares. I exited the final of my Tesla—purchased for a median of $19 on the present break up stage and lengthy earlier than the present craze for “I purchased this automobile earlier than Elon went loopy” bumper stickers—after the election and have been sitting on a pot of money since, ready till I found out what I used to be going to do with it and what the correct timing is. Effectively, biofuels and batteries for the what, and now for the when. Someone on-line was surprised that I had divested TSLA and was contemplating biofuels, however I feel it’s the correct name. And my batteries ETFs embrace BYD amongst a whole lot of different Chinese language battery and EV corporations.
This portfolio shift doesn’t change my investments in wind, photo voltaic, or grid infrastructure EFTs, my China digital economic system investments or the Apple inventory I purchased at some a lot lower cost misplaced to the mists of historical past. It enhances them. Biofuels aren’t going to switch electrons, and so they’re not the common reply to decarbonization. However for the segments of worldwide vitality the place combustion isn’t optionally available, and the place electrification will likely be gradual or partial, these corporations provide a viable path to sustainable vitality. They’re not making hydrogen hype. They’re not pretending each flight can run on batteries. They’re grinding biomass into one thing helpful and low-carbon, with clients who want it and insurance policies that assist it.
With the Worldwide Maritime Group’s current passing of arduous web zero necessities for 2050 with as much as $380 per ton fines for lacking discount targets, biofuels are going to be getting hotter once more.
I received’t purchase all 5. I may not even be capable of purchase the three I would like resulting from arcane guidelines about Canadian RSPs, though I’ve different money available outdoors of that a part of my portfolio, so could make investments regardless. However I got here away from the evaluation with a clearer view of who’s more likely to be producing actual molecules for hard-to-abate sectors 5 years from now. If the world nonetheless wants liquid fuels—and it’ll—I wish to maintain shares within the firms making the cleanest, most cost-effective, and most scalable ones. That’s what this sector gives: not fantasy, however purposeful local weather options. And in a portfolio designed for the lengthy transition, that’s value proudly owning.
Whether or not you could have solar energy or not, please full our newest solar energy survey.
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Wish to promote? Wish to recommend a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.
Join our each day publication for 15 new cleantech tales a day. Or join our weekly one if each day is just too frequent.
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
CleanTechnica’s Remark Coverage
