Welcome to Ask Jerry, the place we speak about any and all of the questions you might need in regards to the sensible issues in your life. I am Jerry, and I’ve spent the higher a part of my life working with tech. I’ve a background in engineering and R&D and have been masking Android and Google for the previous 15 years.
I am additionally actually good at researching information about all the pieces — that is an enormous a part of our job right here at Android Central — and I like to assist individuals (one other large a part of our job!). You probably have questions on your tech, I would love to speak about them.
Electronic mail me at askjerryac@gmail.com , and I am going to attempt to get issues sorted out. You may stay nameless should you like, and we promise we’re not sharing something we do not cowl right here.
I look ahead to listening to from you!
Why is Bluetooth nonetheless so dangerous?
(Picture credit score: Tshaka Armstrong)
Nameless asks:
Bluetooth has been round for over 25 years and it is nonetheless unreliable in comparison with Wi-Fi and even mobile. Until I take advantage of matching tools from Apple or Samsung I’ve nothing however issues with buffering and connection points. Why is that this nonetheless occurring in 2024?
Thanks upfront
Hiya! I perceive your frustration and agree that Bluetooth appears to have extra points than Wi-Fi and mobile (supplied you could have a great connection) generally . That is the important thing phrase right here, generally. And for some individuals, in some locations.
The brief reply for individuals who aren’t excited about going deeper: Bluetooth makes use of a closely congested slice of frequency, is dependent upon a number of completely different proprietary applied sciences, and completely different units have completely different additions on high of all of it.
If you happen to’re in the best (mistaken) place on the proper (mistaken) time utilizing the best (mistaken) tools, you are going to have a nasty time. In any other case, Bluetooth could be dependable and even nice — it’s for tens of millions of individuals.
Bluetooth is a bit like a layer cake. The base, bare-bones implementation could be open-source and brazenly obtainable utilizing principally open {hardware}, and that is nice. However nearly no person makes use of it that manner as a result of will probably be precisely what’s described above — unreliable — more often than not.
(Picture credit score: Nicholas Sutrich / Android Central)
Firms like Intel, Apple, Qualcomm, and different tech conglomerates have constructed helpful additions that make Bluetooth higher, extra dependable, and even quicker on the identical frequency due to improved compression.
If you happen to purchase an iPhone and a set of AirPods or a Galaxy S24 and a pair of Galaxy Buds , you are in all probability going to have a fantastic expertise as a result of each side on the {hardware} entrance use the identical software program and have been constructed to work particularly effectively with one another.
That does not imply they will not work effectively with different tools. It simply signifies that they’ve been designed to work finest with one another. Different, usually cheap equipment and tools , might not have the identical additions to Bluetooth and might’t make the most of larger output power or higher compression, and the expertise is not going to be the identical.
Chances are high it is nonetheless going to be good although, as a result of the most important points with Bluetooth rely upon the opposite tools round you.
It is getting crowded in right here
With out stepping into the numbers and buffers, or the intricacies of CSMA/CA , Bluetooth operates in the identical “airspace” as 2.4GHz Wi-Fi and loads of unregulated tools. The channels in these frequencies are sometimes crowded and when a number of the units make no effort to intelligently work with different tools, it may be a large number.
(Picture credit score: Supply: Joe Maring / Android Central)
The most important offenders relating to Bluetooth community interference are (consider it or not) microwave ovens and previous cordless landline telephones. Each emit indicators (within the case of a microwave, it is a byproduct) within the 2.4GHz vary and can intrude with each 2.4GHz Wi-Fi and Bluetooth. Microwaves are particularly problematic as a result of they have no idea they’re inflicting interference and easily don’t care; hit the button to start out them up, and so they leak radio waves by means of previous inefficient seals in all places.
Bluetooth and a couple of.4GHz Wi-Fi can also intrude with one another, however that is the place CSMA/CA (Provider Sense A number of Entry with Collision Avoidance) comes into play. It is a community protocol that units use to actively keep away from interference and more often than not it does a great job.
When Bluetooth indicators are confronted with interference there could be audio buffering, connection points, and connections dropping intermittently. There will not be something you are able to do about it apart from transfer some place else.
As older units are phased out and previous tools is changed with newer and extra environment friendly tools, the issue will “repair” itself.
These seemingly small issues can all add as much as be the explanation why Bluetooth is dangerous for one particular person whereas it is nice for one more. The tools and your location are vital items of the puzzle. Do not write off the know-how as a result of it clearly works effectively for tens of millions of individuals, even when it really works poorly for you.
