Join day by day information updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!
In latest posts to his social media website, Elon Musk took goal at a troublesome goal: the Lockheed-Martin F-35 Lightning II. Not solely is it stealthy (one thing Musk claims to have a workaround for), however he additionally thinks it’s a financial boondoggle that his unofficial “authorities company” ought to attempt to do away with to avoid wasting the taxpayers cash. On this article, I need to clarify why he’s not solely unsuitable concerning the cash and the way forward for fighter jets, however that he’s additionally risking a program with actual environmental advantages.
Let’s Begin With The Gas Financial savings & Emissions Reductions
I do know it in all probability sounds not solely foolish, however flat-out idiotic, to assert {that a} fighter jet can have a optimistic environmental affect. In any case, fighter jets are among the many least environment friendly automobiles in existence. In relation to how a lot gasoline they burn, they make the least environment friendly brodozer pickup vehicles appear to be a bicycle. We’d all be higher off if we might obtain world peace, floor all of them, and sing Kumbaya or no matter. Jets dangerous, amirite?
However, given their important position in securing freedom and security in democratic nations, they’re not one thing we are able to simply do with out to avoid wasting the setting, at the very least not in the true world. There’s at all times some autocratic regime, depraved authoritarian spiritual or political philosophy, or terror group on the market stirring up bother and making it obligatory without spending a dime nations to defend themselves. I do know that’s an enormous simplification, as free-er nations aren’t at all times as free as they need to be, fire up among the issues themselves, and will in all probability do higher at diplomacy, however all in all, we are able to’t simply ditch fighter jets.
This having been stated, their horrible contributions to greenhouse fuel emissions aren’t one thing that may’t enhance, and the insane quantities of cash they value isn’t one thing we are able to’t do higher on. That’s precisely what the F-35 achieves.
In response to Protection One, the F-35 makes use of vastly much less gasoline than related older jet plane. On a hypothetical journey from Guam to Taiwan throughout a battle over the nation, 18 F-15EX fighters (a vastly-improved model of the growing old F-15 fighter) would burn about 491,000 gallons of gasoline, together with gasoline wanted to convey extra gasoline on tankers. F-35s working the identical mission would devour far much less gasoline and require fewer tankers for refueling, totaling about 253,000 gallons of gasoline.
In different phrases, the F-35 makes use of simply over half of the gasoline that various fighters would use. Saving 238,000 gallons of gasoline isn’t any laughing matter, both. When you think about that the typical automobile on the street right this moment will use about 2,693 gallons of gasoline throughout its lifetime, that implies that for simply this one mission, as a lot gasoline is saved as could be switching 88 automobiles out for EVs. And that’s only for one mission!
However, Isn’t The F-35 Program Troubled and Approach Too Costly?
In the event you imagine many media studies, you’d suppose that the F-35 is a horrible fighter jet. It’s dangerous at preventing different planes, it’s received severe flaws and crashes a LOT, and it’s a financially-troubled program that’s losing huge quantities of taxpayer cash to ship that terrible efficiency.
However … that couldn’t be farther from the reality!
I received’t spend a bunch of time on this problem, however briefly, it’s an issue of “If it bleeds, it leads.” When dangerous issues occur, media shops are throughout it as a result of it’s fascinating sufficient to get eyeballs and clicks, and people eyeballs and clicks are important to creating a dwelling within the enterprise. However, the nice issues, how issues have modified since previous studies, and deeper truths are one thing readers and viewers yawn at.
On high of media biases towards dangerous information, there’s additionally the issue of Russian and Chinese language disinformation. If the US has an awesome program doing good issues for its army, you possibly can wager that these nations would have an curiosity in making an attempt to get that program shut down. In any case, their packages are really troubled, they usually merely can’t compete with the F-35, the older however extra maneuverable F-22, and plenty of different American methods. I’ll come again to this in a bit.
The reality is that this system has overcome preliminary issues (like all previous jet packages that have been troubled at first). The fee per aircraft is cheaper than the F-15EX and falling, making it an awesome deal in comparison with absolutely anything in manufacturing right this moment. Its security document is improbable when you think about that nicely over 1,000 planes have been constructed, making the losses decrease than most different planes. It could possibly additionally drastically outperform one of the best planes Russia and China have to supply.
It’s a profitable program by any measure and it’s solely enhancing with time! It’s not a failure.
Why Not Simply Swap To Drones To Save Even Extra Gas and Cash?
One different factor Musk claims is that it might be less expensive to simply exchange the F-35 with drones. Unmanned platforms must be cheaper, much less dangerous for individuals on our facet flying them, and will seemingly use even much less gasoline than the F-35. However, as soon as once more, that’s simply not place to take.
The chilly, onerous truth is that constructing rockets (even very nice rockets) doesn’t give one a familiarity with preventing wars. It could be silly to disclaim that Elon Musk is a genius, and is able to doing nice pondering, however simply as with computer systems, one of the best laptop’s outputs will solely be nearly as good as its inputs. It’s the outdated “rubbish in, rubbish out,” combined with a little bit of “keep in your lane.” Musk understands know-how, however he doesn’t perceive techniques the best way army planners who selected the F-35 do.
Whereas drones are spectacular and may do unprecedented issues, drones are a really totally different instrument for a really totally different job. Drones have an actual future within the army area, however they will’t be at their best with out somebody ordering them round. The F-35 has been designed to behave as a quarterback within the sky, serving to give the human within the loop unprecedented quantities of helpful data to make higher choices. This data will allow F-35 pilots to successfully work with entire teams of “loyal wingman” drones.
In different phrases, the F-35 was constructed to work in live performance with drones! Eliminating it in favor of drones would make nearly zero sense, particularly in case you’re optimistic about the way forward for autonomous drone know-how. The F-35 is constructed to be an awesome manned platform within the brief time period whereas being prepared for much extra drones in the long run as they develop into higher. The aircraft is a bit like a Tesla in that it’s an honest automobile that may develop into higher when unsupervised FSD turns into a actuality.
It’s not a query of drones vs. fighters. It’s a query of drones AND fighters.
Creating a brand new drone fighter to switch the F-35’s position in such a kill net wouldn’t be cheaper to function, both. You’d be ranging from scratch growing a brand new fighter, taking over all the growth prices and dangers that the F-35 overcame in its earlier years. It could take a while to get to the purpose the place that program’s prices dropped all the way down to the prices that the F-35 has achieved and turns into a really good choice financially to switch it.
Fighter jets are additionally doing much more than merely carrying missiles into fight. Fighter pilots do much more than that, and should make a number of essential choices with incomplete data. Plans want to vary mid-flight in lots of circumstances, and AI will choke on coping with choices exterior of coaching for a while now. It’s a difficulty that AI methods may by no means actually have the ability to absolutely overcome, per AI specialists, as a result of AI fashions aren’t nice at figuring out whether or not information is related to the duty at hand. That is one thing our ventromedial prefrontal cortex is already extraordinarily good at.
Superior air protection methods and using AI and cameras merely aren’t capable of hurt jets the best way Elon Musk claims. Methods just like the F-35 don’t work to easily fly proper in as if invisible and defeat these methods by means of sheer technological superiority. A wealth of expertise working stealth plane and utilizing them successfully towards radar methods additionally comes into play, and that’s not one thing that autonomous plane can simply do on their very own but.
Last Ideas
On high of all the above, we are able to’t overlook that Musk has had personal conversations with Vladimir Putin, will get particular favors from the Chinese language authorities at Tesla, and has ties to individuals and organizations which were caught repeatedly working towards America’s pursuits as a result of they’re on the Russian payroll. When he falsely says that the F-35 is a nasty and/or out of date program, now we have to maintain that background in thoughts. Even giving him the complete advantage of the doubt and assuming he’s not within the bag for overseas pursuits, we all know that he’s getting a number of data from people who find themselves nearer to Putin and Xi.
It’s additionally essential to needless to say, at the very least in army planning, concepts are solely actually helpful when you possibly can take motion on them. Even with Elon Musk being a really sensible particular person, common concepts like switching to autonomous drones sound good, and mirror the seemingly future trajectory of warfare, however they aren’t helpful with out an precise plan for getting there from the place we’re right this moment. The F-35 is a part of an precise plan to get there from right here, and now we have to maintain taking place that path till a sensible various is able to exchange it.
Featured picture by the Cynthia Griggs, U.S. Air Pressure (Public Area, Authorities Work). Use of DoD imagery doesn’t suggest endorsement.
Chip in a number of {dollars} a month to assist help impartial cleantech protection that helps to speed up the cleantech revolution!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica? Wish to promote? Wish to counsel a visitor for our CleanTech Speak podcast? Contact us right here.
Join our day by day e-newsletter for 15 new cleantech tales a day. Or join our weekly one if day by day is just too frequent.
CleanTechnica makes use of affiliate hyperlinks. See our coverage right here.
CleanTechnica’s Remark Coverage