Foolish Rumor Of The Week — Tesla To Purchase Nissan

Join each day information updates from CleanTechnica on electronic mail. Or observe us on Google Information!

Final Up to date on: twenty second February 2025, 12:12 am

Nissan is floundering. In December, it began cozying as much as Honda to see if the 2 corporations might come to some kind of modus vivendi that will assist it halt its lengthy decline, an concept that former Nissan CEO Carlos Ghosn referred to as “a determined proposal.” Nissan has been struggling for a while with an outdated product portfolio and ongoing quarterly losses. It’s now proposing to shut a few of its factories and lay off as much as 9,000 staff. After almost three months of talks, no settlement could possibly be reached and the pair elected to go their separate methods. Foxconn is alleged to be ready within the wings and is reported to be desirous about entering into the automobile manufacturing enterprise. Nonetheless, it seems the Japanese authorities is none too thrilled a few Taiwanese company taking management of certainly one of its main producers. Within the meantime, the financial outlook for Nissan is getting darker with on daily basis that passes.

ArsTechnica is reporting this week that senior politicians in Japan should not keen to see Nissan fail. The Japanese authorities has been looking for a suitor and had hoped that Honda would do its patriotic obligation and save its rival from extinction. The deal fell aside final week after Renault demanded a worth premium for its shares in Nissan, and Nissan demanded a merger of equals with Honda, even though the market capitalization of Honda is 5 occasions that of Nissan. In actuality, it was all the time going to be a takeover, with little or no in it for Honda in the way in which of complimentary product traces or entry to new applied sciences.

The Nissan Tesla Rumor

On Friday, February 21, 2025, a rumor surfaced that former Japanese Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga was a part of a gaggle that’s making an attempt to get Tesla to spend money on Nissan. Prime Pace says Suga nonetheless sits in Japan’s decrease home of parliament and a few of Nissan’s manufacturing and different services are in his district. Such a merger appears extremely unlikely, even when Tesla CEO Elon Musk was not fully distracted by his quest to dismantle the federal authorities and its workforce, Ars mentioned. Whereas the corporate nonetheless maintains a ridiculous market capitalization due to retail buyers who consider it’s poised to promote billions of humanoid robots to each human on earth, as an automaker it might be struggling virtually as a lot as Nissan.

Ars went on to say that a number of properly knowledgeable individuals advised it final yr Tesla just isn’t a properly run enterprise. Like Nissan, its product vary suffers from having fashions which might be outdated in comparison with the competitors. It seems that shoppers have turned towards the model in Europe and more and more within the US. As well as, its quarterly monetary outcomes have been disappointing just lately. Tesla’s free money circulate fell by 18 p.c in 2024 to $3.6 billion. Nonetheless, its share worth is so excessive that it might pay for an acquisition of Nissan with fairness ought to it select to take action.

The Monetary Instances Began It

In line with CBT Information, the rumors began with a Monetary Instances story which mentioned the funding proposal was led by former Tesla board member Hiro Mizuno. In a swift response on X, Mizuno denied the claims, stating that he “has completely no involvement” in such a gaggle and expressing doubt that Tesla can be desirous about buying Nissan’s crops. Elon Musk additionally dismissed the Monetary Instances report. Like Mizuno, Musk emphasised that Tesla’s manufacturing facility design is exclusive and in contrast to something different automakers have. His firm’s manufacturing course of is a key aggressive benefit, he mentioned, and taking up Nissan’s factories wouldn’t present important worth to Tesla. If it did purchase Nissan’s manufacturing services, it will face the tough job of retrofitting them to accommodate its specialised manufacturing processes. Doing so would seemingly show extra pricey than merely constructing new factories from the bottom up.

With each Musk and Mizuno refuting the proposal, Nissan now finds itself going through an unsure future. It’s changing into more and more clear that the automaker will want a associate to outlive within the present market, however it’s equally dedicated to sustaining its independence. That’s making a difficult balancing act. Desperately needing exterior assist whereas fiercely holding onto its autonomy, Nissan seems to be at a crossroads, CBT Information says.

There’s a whole lot of backtracking happening with these non-merger discussions, Prime Pace says, and the background is vital. Talks with Honda apparently fell by partially as a result of Honda felt like they have been getting a uncooked deal from Nissan President Makoto Uchida, who didn’t need Nissan to change into a subsidiary of Honda. Former Prime Mininster Suga’s workplace denied information of the merger talks with Tesla, as did former Tesla board member Mizuno. Then Musk shortly rejected the very notion of profiting from the Nissan manufacturing services in Tennessee and Mississippi. In principle, the upside for Tesla can be avoiding the looming risk of tariffs on all imported items that at the moment are anticipated to enter impact in April.

On Friday morning Musk tweeted, “The Tesla manufacturing facility IS the product. The Cybercab manufacturing line is like nothing else within the automotive trade.” The interpretation Prime Pace placed on that assertion by Musk is that standard transportation is final century’s know-how and robotaxis, reasonably than Pathfinders and Frontiers, are what People need subsequent. To be honest, gross sales of Nissan automobiles and vehicles are down due to the monetary turmoil surrounding the corporate, however how precisely do you choose up a load of mulch or your children from soccer apply in a nonexistent robotaxi, Prime Pace requested? If Tesla isn’t planning on making a extra reasonably priced Mannequin 3 or one thing like that, the corporate’s already broken gross sales are unlikely to see an uptick.

Is Tesla Viable?

What Prime Pace is suggesting, with out saying so straight, is that regardless of its lofty share worth, Tesla will not be in all that a lot better monetary well being than Nissan and will even discover itself in a state of affairs just like Nissan’s if it it not cautious. Slapping some new head and tail lights on the Mannequin 3 and Mannequin Y could also be welcome information however doesn’t actually offset the truth that Tesla has not had a brand new mass market car in almost 4 years. Folks can disagree concerning the Cybertruck, however as far as we will inform, its gross sales alone received’t considerably have an effect on the corporate’s backside line. The competitors in China is cranking out new fashions each few months. Compared, Tesla is properly behind the curve and it’s onerous to see how a two-seat Cybercab will attraction to patrons who don’t need to be within the taxi enterprise.

The picture Prime Pace leaves us with is 2 shipwrecked sailors clinging to one another in an effort to keep away from drowning. That’s most likely too pessimistic, however then once more, Tesla appears to assume the traditional dynamics of the automobile enterprise honed over 100 years don’t apply to it. As Elon continues to piss individuals off — a bizarre gross sales technique if there ever was one — the fortunes of his firm might bitter unexpectedly, leaving Tesla looking for a lifeline at some future time the way in which Nissan is at this time.