New Apple Magic Keyboard with USB-C and Contact ID Evaluation

The brand new Apple Magic Keyboard, up to date with USB-C, is a tremendous possibility if you’d like Contact ID and if you happen to like laptop-style membrane keyboards. It’s not my most popular typing expertise. It additionally, sadly, solely is available in a restricted variety of colours and solely two sizes.

It’s the inventory keyboard that comes if you happen to order an iMac. It’s additionally out there if you’d like an exterior keyboard in your Mac mini, Mac Studio or a desktop-docked MacBook.

The Magic Keyboard is the one solution to get Contact ID on the Mac, which is a fairly glorious expertise. You simply must pay the relatively excessive worth for it — and the even higher sacrifice of giving up on a clicky mechanical keyboard.

This submit accommodates affiliate hyperlinks. Cult of Mac could earn a fee while you use our hyperlinks to purchase gadgets.

Apple Magic Keyboard Evaluation

Desk of Contents:

1. Design
2. Contact ID
3. Key feeling
4. Compact structure
5. Full-size structure
6. No multi-device pairing
7. Do you have to purchase an Apple Magic Keyboard?

Design

The Magic Keyboard is a chameleon. It completely matches the scale of the Magic Trackpad you might have sitting close by. The blacks look precisely the identical, despite the fact that the keycaps are plastic and the trackpad is glass. With an iMac, it is available in six color-coordinated hues that match the colour laptop you get.

The typeface is San Francisco, the system font used on all Apple platforms since 2015. It’s a phenomenal font that’s extremely legible. The symbols and icons on the modifier keys and performance keys are attractive as effectively.

Even the on-off change is superbly machined with a implausible click on motion to it.

Pairing it with a Mac is straightforward; simply flip it on and briefly plug it in. And you may plug it in with the great braided (and color-matching) USB-C cable it comes with; ditch the Lightning cable out of your desk.

Contact ID

The elective Contact ID key makes signing into your Mac, autofilling a password in Safari, signing in with a Passkey and shopping for merchandise with Apple Pay a lot simpler. Simply maintain your finger on the particular key (or you’ll be able to click on it, if you happen to want) and it’ll immediately authenticate. You may as well click on the button at any time to immediately lock your Mac — a lot quicker than the Command-Management-Q keyboard shortcut. The Contact ID key has a unique change than the opposite keys; it takes extra pressure to press so that you’re much less prone to click on it by chance.

With out Contact ID, you might have a Lock key as an alternative. Which is definitely extra helpful in 2024 than the CD Eject key that was as a replacement earlier than. You may as well pair your Mac with an Apple Watch, and get all the identical options — although the interface is rather less elegant. It’s a lot simpler urgent your finger on a key (the place your palms already are) than it’s reaching over and double-clicking your Apple Watch’s aspect button to verify.

The combo of whether or not Contact ID is offered and which colours include what’s complicated. The compact structure comes each with and with out Contact ID, however solely in white (or, if bought with an iMac, six colours). The complete-size Magic Keyboard comes each with and with out Contact ID, though solely the Contact ID mannequin is available in black — and, black prices $20 additional.

Key feeling

Because the snootiest of mechanical keyboard snobs, I’m now not impressed by the typing feeling of the Magic Keyboard.

It’s among the best, so far as laptop-style membrane keyboards go. The keys are very secure and don’t wobble. There’s a fairly sized hole between every key. There’s a noticeable click on feeling with a quiet however audible sound with each key press. It’s nothing you aren’t used to and nothing about it is going to shock you.

However I nonetheless discovered myself making extra typos. The keys aren’t curved, so except your fingers hit the very fringe of the important thing, you don’t understand how near the middle you’re hitting. I like a keyboard with extra journey, the place the keys must be pressed down additional to register.

Folks say that solely “a foul workman blames his instruments.” And it’s normally true {that a} professional gaming chair gained’t make you a greater gamer, an costly knife set gained’t make you a greater cook dinner, a pair of racing gloves gained’t make you a greater driver. However as somebody with a examined typing pace of 83 phrases per minute, I can confidently say it’s completely true {that a} dangerous keyboard will maintain you again.

Compact structure

The compact structure saves house in your desk. Personally, I want compact keyboards. I don’t want a full quantity pad; I’m not an accountant. I additionally like having a brief journey between the alphanumeric keys and my trackpad.

The most important draw back is the arrow keys. The Left and Proper keys are the identical top because the mixed Up and Down keys, so it’s arduous to establish them by really feel. Apple makes use of this similar keyboard structure on the MacBook Professional, besides as of 2021, the arrow keys are fastened to be T-shaped. I don’t know why the desktop keyboard will get overlooked. And on the colourful iMac Magic Keyboard, it might be good if you happen to had a sq. the place you may actually see the colour shine by way of.

Sadly, you don’t have bodily keys for Web page Up, Web page Down, House, Finish and Ahead Delete. You need to use Possibility-Up, Possibility-Down, Command-Up, Command-Down and Perform-Delete to get the identical performance, however that normally requires utilizing each palms, and isn’t as quick.

My very best compact keyboard structure has full-size arrow and navigation keys, however with out the quantity pad. Amongst keyboard fanatics, this is named the tenkeyless or 87% structure.

Full-size structure

The complete-size structure is a extra commonplace keyboard structure.

You could have Command, Possibility and Management on each side of the keyboard, organized in that order, symmetrically, going out from the spacebar.

It doesn’t waste any house on these pointless PC keys — Insert, SysRq, Scroll Lock, Pause/Break. As a substitute, you might have a Context Menu key. (This was beforehand the Perform key, however that’s been moved to the underside left, like on the MacBook keyboard.) I’m undecided how helpful that is, however not less than I do know what it does.

The opposite keys, F13 – F19, are clean. You possibly can assign your individual actions to them if you happen to dig by way of System Settings.

The large floor space it occupies in your desk makes you assume it ought to be heavier than it really is. Though it’s product of steel, I don’t assume it’s artificially weighted in any respect. I’ve used loads of smaller, extra compact plastic keyboards which might be over twice as heavy. It’s very nice.

No multi-device pairing

AirPods use clever pairing. They’ll successfully keep paired to a number of gadgets without delay, in order that switching between your Apple Watch, iPhone, iPad and Mac is seamless. You probably have a number of Macs sharing one desk, you won’t need two mice, or two keyboards or two trackpads. It might probably get complicated and crowded.

However alas, all of Apple’s newest peripherals nonetheless use vanilla Bluetooth, and don’t benefit from Apple’s personal expertise elsewhere.

Apple’s reply to that want is Common Management, which lets one keyboard management a number of gadgets — even a Mac and iPad — however that solely works if all of the gadgets are subsequent to one another and on the identical Apple account. You probably have a piece laptop computer and a private laptop computer, they’re most likely on completely different Apple accounts. Continuity isn’t true multi-device pairing; the keyboard solely stays paired to 1 Mac, which acts as a relay. Take that Mac away, and your Magic Keyboard gained’t be linked to the opposite one.

Evaluation Conclusion: Do you have to purchase the brand new Apple Magic Keyboard?

Personally, I wouldn’t use the Apple Magic Keyboard. I don’t assume it’s good sufficient to justify its excessive costs, and neither of the configurations match what I would like.

However as a result of I don’t assume Apple goes to make a tenkeyless mannequin in black (and since I don’t like membrane keyboards, anyway) what I really need is an answer for these of us who like third-party keyboards but in addition need Contact ID. Ideally, that may be Contact ID constructed into the Magic Trackpad.

★★★☆☆

Purchase from: Amazon (White, Compact)
Purchase from: Amazon (Black, Full-size)

Apple didn’t present Cult of Mac with a overview unit for this text. See our critiques coverage, and take a look at different in-depth critiques of Apple-related gadgets.